
The boys told me that our book selection is basically terrible. We had thinned out a bunch of the “little” kid stories, but I always saved their favorites. So, when we sat and tidied the shelf, I was shocked to hear:
“George – get rid of it, we hate him.”
“WHAT?” My heart lurched. “You would BEG me to read that entire book, there are six different stories in there. You’d make me read every one, sometimes twice.”
Shrugs from the boys.
“Hate this one.” What? Magic School Bus? On the discard pile?
And so on. Enter a “we hate” before a treasured childhood book, rip moms heart out, repeat.
How can this be? What is happening here? This is insanity. They begged me to read these stories time and again. I’d leave dishes in the sink, clothes unfolded, floors unswept, to snuggle and read these exact books.
Sigh. It’s natural human progression happening here and I have no power to stop it. Well, I have a little power. I’ll make a list of their ten favorite toddler/preschool years stories to somehow preserve them and I’ll box those books away to soothe my soul. Their trash, my treasure. (If you’ve followed my tidying posts, yes, these books are getting stored, yes, they “spark joy.”) Don’t get me wrong though, I adore that I can read them Jurassic Park and they actually understand it. It’s all part of this growing journey.
Anyhow, in no specific order, here are the ten most read stories I could have recited by heart a few years ago, which will sadly now be in our garage in a plastic tote.
1. Curious George: You name it, we read it, vintage George, new George, even in Spanish George. Curious George stories were well-loved and received. The New Adventures of Curious George will stay in my box forever.
2. Magic School Bus: I loved Miss Frizzle as a child and loved reading the vintage copies as an adult. The boys enjoyed At the Waterworks and Lost in the Solar System the most.
3. Blueberries for Sal by Robert McCloskey. I adore the front and back inside cover illustration. It reminds me so much of my older son who would carry and wear canning jar rings on his arms as a toddler. The illustrations throughout are beautiful, the story adorable.
4. If You Give a Mouse a Cookie by Laura Joffe Numeroff. I can totally get behind a book that plays on the insanity of raising a little one. The boys laughed at the silly demands of the mouse, while I laughed at how true this story could be.
5. The Glorious Flight Across the Channel with Louis Bleriot by Alice and Martin Provensen. This book is a fabulous motivator. When the kiddos were struggling with failed attempts we’d remember Louis Bleriot who just wouldn’t give up.
6. Little Blue and Little Yellow by Leo Lionni. This book came to us second-hand and tattered. I always thin out books, but somehow, even beat up, this one never made it out the door. Simple friendship and color mixing make a quick, nice story to enjoy.
7. What is Your Language by Debra Leventhal. “What is your language, please tell me now…” Oh sorry, the title made me go into a little a chant. Yup, read this one a LOT. My younger fella particularly enjoyed it. The refrain repeats for multitudes of languages. I guess he liked to hear me try to speak Japanese?
8. Madeline by Ludwig Bemelmans. Another rhymer. I adore the vintage illustrations. The boys enjoyed the story.
9. Mirette on the High Wire by Emily Arnold McCully. My younger son is always there to point out that books with medals on the covers are the winners. (He is also known to draw medals on his own books.) Mirette is a young daring girl ready to take on the high wire and help a man who loses faith in his ability.
10. Just Me and My Mom by Mercer Mayer. Another load of books I loved as a girl and saw the humor in as an adult. Mercer Mayer’s books made quick reads. We loved and owned many of them. I kept the mom one for obvious reasons.
It’s not all sigh and sad though, some loved books made it back on the shelf. In fact, my younger son has followed me around the house with Mine-O-Saur, this week, because we sorted through and it’s been found. I’ll probably share those someday, but I’m okay if it’s in a few years.